Displaying 251 - 275 of 306

 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason
19036West ValleyZOECOPENHAVER2.993.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Good w/L record
19140East ValleyJeanneSeger2.993.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE

2.99 EAST VALLEY INDEX FROM 2023
3.16 CASA GRANDE INDEX FROM 24/25

Jeanne is only .01 from 3.0 East Valley from '23
She played Casa Grande for the last 2 years
Jeanne has played 3.0 for several years.
17960East ValleyDonnaVarnell2.973.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
  • Duplicate Appeal
18822West ValleyCatherine (Cati)Ackley2.973.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

first year was 2025
w 24 losses 10
high point scores on losses to add to team totals
18126West ValleyMikiDammarell2.963.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Won 73%
Dominated 2.5

Approve
18028West ValleyPerriGuido2.953.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
17956Casa GrandeTerryVoth2.943.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

eligible for Fast track
17966East ValleyDonnaVarnell2.943.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

YES APPROVE

ONLY .06 FROM 3.0

PLAYED SCOTTSDALE LEAGUE IN 2025
3.2 RATING IN THIS LEAGUE
PLAYED ON 3.0 TEAM IN 2024
19462SouthernCarolPinkerton-Ewens2.923.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Carol played 24 games in the 2025 season only. She won 6 and lost 18. She is eligible for a fast-track appeal to play 3.0. I do not think she should be approved for appeal to 3.5 based on her professional coach DUPR rating

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
18213West ValleyMaryBrockman2.903.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Dominated division
good w/l percentage 70%
and low points allowed by opponents
APPROVE
17814SouthernPamHolmes2.893.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025 due to injury

2024 14 wins 15 losses earned 8 appl points, allowed 5
never rose above the 3.1 mark in 2024
Injured in 2025, back surgery
no pb or dupr ratings

would have qualified for a fast track appeal. Recommend approval.

18789West ValleyLaurieLutz2.883.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
19039West ValleyPamLeeming2.883.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Didn't play in 2025, only 6 games in 2024

Self rating via Appeal process
17895East ValleyDianneBirgenheir2.873.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

YES APPROVE

Dianne played 2.5/3.0 division in 2025

Won some, lost some and split some

She should be consistent at 3.0 and competitive.
17863SouthernPamSteube2.863.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

After multiple conversations with Pam about a fast track appeal as she qualifies.....
she said she was denied the first one at this rating.
I asked her to resubmit and she said it wouldn't let her.

Approve the appeal as it really qualifies for a fast track but technology glitches or operator error are making it impossible to submit the appropriate one.

18107SouthernKarenKelly2.843.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Karen is .01 off of what would be an auto appeal. Two years ago she was injured in a bicycle crash in August 2023 that broke her spine, her pelvis and her arm. It was months before she was out of the hospital and at home again. She did not play last year until May 2025 when she was finally released to do so.

Karen has been down at ACE every single day taking lessons, working on the ball machine and playing with 3.0 and 3.5 players.

Her tenacity warrants a 3.0 rating if nothing else. She was literally shattered into many pieces.

17885West ValleyBarbaraLucas2.833.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

incorrect start rating -- 2.52, should have been 2.70

W 15, L 3 dominated 2.5
18007SouthernRobertSalter2.833.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Robert played 34 games last yea He lost 24 mens doubles matches, won 3. He lost 4 mixed double and won 3. He earned 6 appl points in mens doubles and allowed 2. He won 3 apple points in mixed and allowed two.

He struggled all year with leg issues eventually having surgery to correct it. He states that subs scores might have been attributed to him but I would have know way of knowing if this was accurate.

He played in 65+ last year and can do so again this year if he so chooses. In adding up all matches both doubles and mixed his average rating is a 2.9. I believe that he should be granted the appeal based on that, due to the unknown of whose scores are actually entered and no way to find out. If he chooses to play 65+ he is able to regardless.

Duper is 3.006
17794SouthernNancyCuzman2.823.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Nancy has been a solid 3.0 player for several years. As a coach/captain, Nancy ends up playing with the players no one else wants to play with. Nancy has a good well rounded game. She dinks, can do overheads and thinks about strategy. Nancy is very slightly built and I believe her lack of strength is the only thing that keeps her from being a 3.5 player. I would approve Nancy's appeal as she has done the work to be a 3.0 but constantly puts others first. Her average rating this past year is 2.917 which is well within the auto appeal boundaries.
17799East ValleyTedAlbright2.813.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE 2.81 TO 3.0
**DUPR 3.26 recent
LACK OF GAMES played only 6 in 25
Ted played 80% of '24 season at 3.0 or 2.9
Suffered injuries and then had surgery
Wants to come back at 3.0

Medical injuries for 2025 season
17787SouthernSuzanneRichards2.83.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

In 2025 Suzanne played both mixed and gender doubles.

Gender:
5 wins and 15 losses. Earned 5 appl points in 15 losses
allowed 4 appl points in 5 wins

Mixed:
6 wins and 16 losses Earned 6 appl points in 16 losses and allowed 4 appl points in 6 wins

Dupr is 2.943 She said she played injured last year. Player is 72 years old.

The only thing that makes me want to honor the appeal is the injury and the dupr rating. Her wins and loses do not support it but at 72 she is still playing so maybe she earns it by determination.
17880SouthernSuzanneRichards2.83.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

suzanne started at the given rate of 3.2 and ended at 2.8. Her rating progressed steadily downward.
Mixed play
6 wins 18 losses
appl points scored 5 appl points allowed 1
womens
5 wins 13 losses
appl points scored 7 appl points allowed
The suzanne richards that is 72 as our appl states does not have a pb brackets rating. Her dupr is 2.943 which comes only from a ladder league within her community and no tournament play

she states she has rotator cuff issues.
I don't recommend approval

  • Duplicate Appeal
18079West ValleyWayneCarroll2.83.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

actual APPL Index is 2.85, played on 3.0 last season. should have been a FAST Track
17909East ValleyRobinCastriano2.793.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

REJECT 2.79 TO 3.0
Robin started season at 3.20 AS A NEW PLAYER
She won 2:22lost
152 won: 263Lost
Stay at 2.5

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17938SouthernJamesA Strickland2.783.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

This one was a real pain. I had to look up every single person played as there is no indication within the rating if they were the 18+ team.....ugh

As a 50+ player. He won 15 games, lost 23
Earned 12 appl points and allowed 6.

Against the 18+ he won 2 games, lost 8
Earned 3 appl points and allowed 2

This player was born in 1961 In his losses he lost 1 game to players born in 1976 and 1979
2 games to players born in 1993 and 1966
and 2 games to players born in 1970 and 1969
He lost one game to players born in 1990 and 2000

3 of his games lost were to people less than 10 years younger than him.

In the 18+ matches his rating dropped a total of .15. Added back into his final rating that brings him to a 2.93. Enough for an auto appeal.

 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason