| 17873 | East Valley | June | Gill | 3.65 | 3.0 | Rejected | Workflow Complete | NO REJECT
June won 80% of games in 2025
SPLIT 12% and only lost 7%
She will totally dominate with any partner she plays with and she did play with many different partners which also shows she is dominating at 3.0
June is 65, no apparant medical issues so I feel she should stay at 3.5 where she will be competitive.
She is not on a community based team as she states so should be able to find another team at 3.5
| - Information provided does not support the Appeal
- APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
|
| 17890 | East Valley | Candace | Sharkey | 4.20 | 3.5 | Rejected | Workflow Complete | Candace started 2025 season as a high 3.5 at 3.93
She stayed over 4.0 the entire season and won the majority of games in doubles and mixed.
I would suggest if she wants to play with her same partners they could possibly appeal to 4.0 as they are higher level 3.5 players as well.
Candace will be competitive at 4.0
Her reasoning to stay at 3.5 is to play with the same partners.
| - Information provided does not support the Appeal
- APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
- Medical reasoning does not support the Appeal
|
| 17893 | East Valley | William | Wayne | 4.55 | 4.0 | Rejected | Workflow Complete | NO REJECT
Wayne consistently went over 4.5 throughout the 2025 season. To make it over that 4.5 skill level takes good consistent playing esp with as many games as he played in two teams.
Wayne played with multiple partners and did well thru out the season on a 50+ and a 65+ team. Wayne will be competitive at 4.5.
| - Information provided does not support the Appeal
- APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
|
| 17895 | East Valley | Dianne | Birgenheir | 2.87 | 3.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | YES APPROVE
Dianne played 2.5/3.0 division in 2025
Won some, lost some and split some
She should be consistent at 3.0 and competitive.
| |
| 17898 | East Valley | michelle | shumaker | 4.05 | 3.5 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE from 4.05 TO 3.5
Michelle won ONLY 50% of her games at 3.5
21:21
364 WON 368 LOST POINTS
Michelle played 3.0 in 2024, new to 3.5 in 2025.
Michelle did not dominate at 3.5 and another year at 3.5 will prepare her for 4.0 division.
I think Michelle should stay at 3.5 for another year and see how her statistics are next year.
| |
| 17909 | East Valley | Robin | Castriano | 2.79 | 3.0 | Rejected | Workflow Complete | REJECT 2.79 TO 3.0
Robin started season at 3.20 AS A NEW PLAYER
She won 2:22lost
152 won: 263Lost
Stay at 2.5
| - Information provided does not support the Appeal
- APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
|
| 17931 | East Valley | Michelle | Ford | 4.5 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | YES APPROVE
Michelle barely went over 4.5 with a 4.51
She won 64% of her games and lost 36%
She did not dominate at 4.0
Michelle is 66 and playing on 65+ team that finished 3/4 in that division.
Michelle has a bad knee and lists several PT appts, MRI and steroid injections.. her knee has not been replaced yet so she feels playing at a higher level could be a safety issue for her.
I feel we give her another year at 4.0, see how she plays out this season and gets her knee replacement .
| |
| 17952 | East Valley | Tricia | Montague | 3.96 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | Should be Fast Track
APPROVE
| |
| 17960 | East Valley | Donna | Varnell | 2.97 | 3.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | | |
| 17966 | East Valley | Donna | Varnell | 2.94 | 3.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | YES APPROVE
ONLY .06 FROM 3.0
PLAYED SCOTTSDALE LEAGUE IN 2025
3.2 RATING IN THIS LEAGUE
PLAYED ON 3.0 TEAM IN 2024
| |
| 17967 | East Valley | Henrietta | Wong | 3.09 | 3.5 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 3.09 to 3.5 Greg M agrees
DUPR 3.764
Due to injury, played only one match (6 games) in "2024" season and played with tennis elbow because of shortage of players/ could not play competitively because of this.
CANNOT count these games
SOLid 3.0 in 23/24
Basicly wants to self-rate at 3.5 with CURRENT DUPR which is accurate
Played Pickl League 3.25-3.75
| |
| 17990 | East Valley | Geri | Luciani | 2.75 | 3.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE to 3.0
HOVERING AT 3.99 2025
Last 4 games 2.93 to
2.79 just the last 4 games
263 won 246 lost
50% win/loss
| |
| 18011 | East Valley | Liz | Dubisar | 3.72 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 3.72 to 4.0
Liz stayed right at 3.9 mostly the entire 2025 season until the last 3 games.
Liz has a DUPR & UTPR over 4.0
Played 4.0 in 22/23/24/25 seasons
253 pts won : 362pts loss
Liz is where she needs to be at 4.0
| |
| 18043 | East Valley | James | Johnson | 3.43 | 3.5 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 3.44 to 3.5
DUPR 3.535
Index of 3.44 is from 2024 season. He played elsewhere in 2025.
He is .01 from a 3.5
Can't do fast track because he did not play APPL IN 2025
| |
| 18089 | East Valley | Jiraanong | Manceau | 3.91 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE
3.91 to 4.0 (Last played APPL 2024)
Won 12 Lost 5 Split 2
Plays 4.0 Tournaments
Will be competitive at 4.0
| |
| 18098 | East Valley | angel | singer | 3.83 | 4.0 | Rejected | Workflow Complete | REJECT
Plays at PICKLR at 4.0
2025 season played 4.0
145W 243L
4W 20L
6PPG
| - Information provided does not support the Appeal
- APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
|
| 18105 | East Valley | Sheryl | Erickson | 2.72 | 3.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 2.72 TO 3.0
2026 WON STATE TOURNAMENT
Sheryl and partner won ALL of their games at state
2025 season
423 Won points
554 Lost points
Will dominate this year at 2.5, needs to play 3.0
| |
| 18110 | East Valley | mark | sharkey | 3.86 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 3.86 TO 4.0
Fast track player
| |
| 18115 | East Valley | William (Bill) | Wayne | 4.55 | 4.0 | Rejected | Workflow Complete | REJECT 4.5 to 4.0
BILL IS 67 and played against 50+ players and continues to improve.
Bill played over 100 games 2025 and won 75/lost 27.
290 W
170 L
Averaged almost 10 PPG
Wayne consistently went over 4.5 throughout the 2025 season. To make it over that 4.5 skill level takes good consistent playing esp. with as many games as he played on two teams.
Wayne played with multiple partners and performed very well thru out the season on a 50+ AND a 65+ team. Wayne will be competitive at 4.5.
We "cannot" go here with this one.....even with all the statistics they have submitted, it just doesn't add up.
| - Information provided does not support the Appeal
- APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
|
| 18116 | East Valley | Jim | Knaut | 3.65 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 3.65 TO 4.0
Played all 2025 season with Meniscus tear and a lot of pain affecting his W/L. The meniscus tears in his knee (which to quote the doctor, looked like shredded crab) were surgically repaired in July and he is now back to full speed.
His team got 2nd state 2025 and will now be playing 4.0.
He won about 50% of his games with his bad knee.
He had medical issues, got them fixed and now ready to go strong....
| |
| 18129 | East Valley | Lana | Williams | 3.85 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE
3.85 to 4.0
Beginning of season stayed right above 3.5
Had a strong end of season to 3.85
Plays daily with 4.0+ men and women
W 27 L 13
400W 358L
9.52PPG
| |
| 18132 | East Valley | Douglas | Johnston | 3.45 | 3.5 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE 3.45 TO 3.5
DUPR 3.6
DID NOT PLAY APPL 2025
PLAYED ON 3.5 IN '23
PLAYED IN ALBUQUERQUE other seasons
PLAYS AT MESA REGAL IN THEIR 3.5 GROUP
| |
| 18157 | East Valley | Trung | Lam | 3.79 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE
ONLY played 1 match at the end of 2025 season
Medical issues until then
Team went to State Tournament and got 2nd
Won 8 lost 4
116 W 106 L
Steve and I both agree to give him a chance at 4.0 level this season as if he would have played more during the season, chances are his rating would be over 4.0
| |
| 18161 | East Valley | Paul | Malley | 3.50 | 4.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE
Paul has played MXD with his wife as his partner for 3 years. She actually applied for an appeal from 4.07 to 4.0 which we denied. We told her that her partner could apply for an appeal up and would have a better chance for approval.
Paul is 3.70
Averages almost 9 PPG
231W 217L
Will be competitive at 4.0
| |
| 18168 | East Valley | Earl | Amkin | 3.61 | 3.0 | Approved | Workflow Complete | APPROVE
Medical Appeal
Earl's INDEX has consistently gone down since '22 /'23
playing first in the East Valley. Earl moved to Casa Grande region in 24 and 25 for less competition because of his back issues. His Index continued to decline even in Casa Grande. Early ended the 25 season with a 3.33 rating. Earl feels he needs to be able to play safely in East Valley at 3.0.
His last rating in East Valley from 2023 was 3.61 which does not reflect his recent play.
| |
