Displaying 26 - 50 of 306

 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason
17792East ValleyAnneKennedy4.504.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

REJECT APPEAL from 4.5 to 4.0

Looking at game results from 2025, I don't believe that Anne is not a competitive person at this level.
Dominated at 4.0 doubles
Partner (husband) for MXD is lower level 4.0 so would guess she carried him and the reason his APPL rating did not go up

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17800East ValleyMarkLovelady4.54.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

REJECT APPEAL to 4.0 from 4.5 INDEX

Played consistently and dominated 4.0, medical reasoning does NOT support this appeal.

Discussed with Steve and agrees

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
  • Medical reasoning does not support the Appeal
17931East ValleyMichelleFord4.54.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

YES APPROVE

Michelle barely went over 4.5 with a 4.51
She won 64% of her games and lost 36%
She did not dominate at 4.0
Michelle is 66 and playing on 65+ team that finished 3/4 in that division.
Michelle has a bad knee and lists several PT appts, MRI and steroid injections.. her knee has not been replaced yet so she feels playing at a higher level could be a safety issue for her.
I feel we give her another year at 4.0, see how she plays out this season and gets her knee replacement .
17883West ValleyKirstinJohnson4.494.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete
18068West ValleyMonteWilliams4.464.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

System issue? started 4.0 at a 4.52 APPL Index

Above 4.5 all season except last 2 games
17796West Valleykevindixon4.444.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete
18757SouthernDeeDeeCherubini4.444.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

DeeDee Cherubini is requesting a rate appeal from 4.44 to 4.5. She played 4.0 last year so is not eligible for an autoappeal.

DeeDee was on my team in 2024 and went to Nationals with us and was a big key to our winning the tournament.

DeeDee played on a 4.0 mixed team. She won 15 games and lost one.

She played in a mixed league with 50+ and 18+ women teams. She won 20 games and lost 4.

At state the mixed team took 1st place and the women's team took second.
Her DUPR is a 4.458

DeeDee is well-rounded player still in her 30's and could be an asset to Appl for many years to come.

I request that she be allowed to to appeal to 4.5
18296West ValleyPatrickHansen4.434.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

did not play in 2025

DUPR recent, and above 4.5

Self rate through appeal
18070West ValleyMartyBraden4.424.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

above 4.5 all season but fell last 2 games

Started 2025 in 4.0 with a 4.52 APPL Index

Played in merged pilot 4, 4.5 and 5.0 combined
17882West ValleyAdrianaCunningham4.44.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

dominated 4.0 , w29 l- 5
state 9-3

may have started at too low of a rating
18297West ValleyWayneMosser4.354.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2024 or 2025 seasons

Self rate through appeal process
17811West ValleyChrisStelplugh4.334.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete
18223West ValleyKurtisAmend4.324.5RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
18240West ValleyMingFu4.323.5RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
18295West ValleyLaraMosser4.34.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

hasn't played since 2023
DUPR over 4.5, and recent

Self-rating to 4.5 through appeal
19203West ValleyLeiBerezowski4.34.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Positive W/L record

2025 first year in APPL, probably should have com in at 4.5
19410East ValleyJosephNettemeyer4.294.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE

4.29 to 4.5
Played on 4.5 last year. 18+
Had a groin injury in 25 so had a hard time competing at that level. Is better now and wants to continue at 4.5

141 won. 242 lost.

17877West ValleyMicheleFollger4.284.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Approve
Played in numerous merged flights
17925West ValleyPegBarcelo4.234.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

RD and LC review and approval. Merger flights in pilot group counted and impacted rating.
18065SouthernGeneSeifers4.223.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Gene is petitioning based on medical reasons. Bone on Bone knee in both knees.
He played in only two matches last year both in early January before deciding the combined higher skill and younger age bracket was too much for him.

He won four games lost 8. He earned four appl points and allowed three.

Gene started playing in 2022 with an Appl rating as high as 4.38 at one point. His appl rating never dipped below the 4.0. He is petitioning to play 3.5. He can play on a 65 team but only at 4.0 Gene's dupr is stale at 3.5 in 2021
17890East ValleyCandaceSharkey4.203.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Candace started 2025 season as a high 3.5 at 3.93
She stayed over 4.0 the entire season and won the majority of games in doubles and mixed.

I would suggest if she wants to play with her same partners they could possibly appeal to 4.0 as they are higher level 3.5 players as well.

Candace will be competitive at 4.0

Her reasoning to stay at 3.5 is to play with the same partners.

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
  • Medical reasoning does not support the Appeal
17763West ValleyThierrySimondet4.183.5RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17879West ValleyLindaTompkins4.174.5RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
19442East ValleyDougOsborn4.163.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE
SELF RATE 3.5

Played last in 2022

Back fusion and knee replacement
DUPR 3.248
17844East ValleyMeganMacpherson4.153.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

REJECT APPEAL

Did play in a division including 3.0 teams, but it was to my understanding that those games did not count toward APPL index. MOST teams in division were 3.5 teams and Megan won over 80% of games

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason