Displaying 51 - 75 of 306

 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason
17792East ValleyAnneKennedy4.504.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

REJECT APPEAL from 4.5 to 4.0

Looking at game results from 2025, I don't believe that Anne is not a competitive person at this level.
Dominated at 4.0 doubles
Partner (husband) for MXD is lower level 4.0 so would guess she carried him and the reason his APPL rating did not go up

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17800East ValleyMarkLovelady4.54.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

REJECT APPEAL to 4.0 from 4.5 INDEX

Played consistently and dominated 4.0, medical reasoning does NOT support this appeal.

Discussed with Steve and agrees

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
  • Medical reasoning does not support the Appeal
17808West ValleyAngelaEdmonson3.424.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

Rejected
Added a note to player to resubmit to 3.5
Current request it too large

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17810East ValleyCindySchutt3.834.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE 3.83 to 4.0
.02 fast track

34 W 32 L
561:579
Competitive at 4.0
17819West ValleyPamelaSmith3.734.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17822West ValleyLouiseTobias3.874.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17823West ValleyTronBrinkmann3.964.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
17824West ValleyAndrewTobias3.984.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
17825East ValleyClarenceLindblom3.794.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE appeal to 4.0 from 3.79
STARTED AT 4.2 Played 4 seasons at 4.0
Won 50% of games 15/15. 252:261
Competitive at 4.0
He stayed just barely under 4.0 most of the season
17826West ValleyJulieTisue3.804.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Should have been a Fast track. Julie played 4.0 last season.
I approved rather than asking her to resubmit — outcome is the same.
17836East ValleyLynRube2.614.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • Duplicate Appeal
17837East ValleyLynRube3.614.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

REJECT 3.61 TO 4.0.
65+ TEAM
Lyn is 65 and can play on 4.0 team
Lynn's performance in '25 declined to her significant drop below 4.0

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17839Casa GrandeJanettKline3.834.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
17840East ValleyMaryWaitrovich3.844.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

APPROVE 3.84 to 4.0
.01 from fast track
started season at 4.2
Considered fast track entire season except for the very last match
APPL history supports competitive at 4.0
UTPR and DUPR 4.0+
191:336
17841SouthernCurtisSimpson4.534.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

Curtis Simpson is one of the players that caused a great deal of complaints last year regarding sandbagging. He played as a captain rated player on a 3.5 tear. He won 95 games and lost 7. At state he won 16 games and lost 3. Regular season saw him score 7 appl points in 7 losses and state had 4 appl points scored in 8 losses. Regular season saw 33 appl points scored against him in 95 wins and 5 appl points in 16 wins at state.

His dupr is 3.956. HOWEVER he plays round robin mixers at an indoor club weekly with rotating partners for that dupr score. His dupr has never been over 4.0. Pb brackets is all blurred out and I cannot see it. I do not recommend approval of the appeal

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17847West ValleyJohnAnket3.544.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

2025 W 5, loss 20
DUPR info on at 28% reliability
Index declined from 3.61-3.54 in 2025

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17853East ValleyKathyReam3.834.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

YES APPROVE 3.83 to 4.0. Greg M agrees

Played 4.0 teams for 2 years
and Tournaments 80% medaled
Went from 4.20 to 3.83
Competitive @ 4.0
.02 from FAST TRACK AND ONLY because of her LASt game
17855East ValleyAnnieKloss3.924.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

YES APPROVE

3.92 to 4.0

COULD have done FAST TRACK

STate Champs @3.5
Played all matches at state
17858West ValleyJanePulvermacher4.604.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17861East ValleyKarenTurnlund3.924.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

YES APPROVE

3.92 to 4.0
Could have done a FAST TRACK
17874West ValleyDonnaDoyle3.954.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete
17888West ValleyToriBenz-Hillstrom3.714.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17891West ValleyDanaSullivan3.934.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17892West ValleySelenaHayes3.914.0RejectedWorkflow Complete
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17893East ValleyWilliamWayne4.554.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

NO REJECT

Wayne consistently went over 4.5 throughout the 2025 season. To make it over that 4.5 skill level takes good consistent playing esp with as many games as he played in two teams.

Wayne played with multiple partners and did well thru out the season on a 50+ and a 65+ team. Wayne will be competitive at 4.5.

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason