Roster Rating Standard Appeal

Data does not support moving up.

• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

APPROVE 3.9 TO 4.0

Game HX supports competitive at 4.0
Doubles team won State Tournament 2025

Positive W/L record

2025 first year in APPL, probably should have com in at 4.5

Did not play in 2025
Self rating through appeal process

Played with 18+ mixed flights, scores counted
close to 4.0 both seasons played

Approved

APPROVE
3.85 to 4.0
Beginning of season stayed right above 3.5
Had a strong end of season to 3.85
Plays daily with 4.0+ men and women
W 27 L 13
400W 358L
9.52PPG

• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

REJECT
Played a lot of games last year on 2 teams
Men's and Mxd at 4.0
Climbed consistently all season
I see he "split" games with Bill Wayne who we have also denied appeal to 4.0 from 4.5
W 786 L599
Averages almost 10 ppg
54W 30LKris is strong and needs to play at 4.5 or he will totally dominate this year at 4.0

• Information provided does not support the Appeal
• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

Kim's rating is .01 off a fast track appeal. Wants to appeal to 3.5

Over the past couple of years of play her rating has kind of danced all around the 3.2, 3.3 range. Never over a 3.5

When she played mixed her losses were 17 compared to 7 wins, 4 appl points earned and 8 allowed. That is a 41% win ratio in mixed.

In gender doubles she was 50/50. She had five wins and five losses. She earned 4 appl points and allowed to.

She speaks of two really dominant mixed teams and when I look at them I do see players that play 4.0 regularly in tournaments etc. That might account for the 41% ratio.

She played in 50+ in both of those even though she qualified for 65+. I don't know if it is because Tubac only has 'x' number of teams available.

I have reached out to Naomi Giles from Green Valley to see if she has an opinion on, or knows her play. No response

She is qualified to play on a 65+ team if one is available in Tubac. Limited teams available there. I would be inclined keep her playing and say yes.

She has 14 DUPR matches in 2024. 3.668

Last played in 2022

Self rating via Appeal process

• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

only played 2 matches in 2025 due to her work schedule.
did not play in 2024 - rating too high.
for 2025 self rating, using Appeal to change Roster rating since she has a historical rating