Roster Rating Standard Appeal

Gene is petitioning based on medical reasons. Bone on Bone knee in both knees.
He played in only two matches last year both in early January before deciding the combined higher skill and younger age bracket was too much for him.

He won four games lost 8. He earned four appl points and allowed three.

Gene started playing in 2022 with an Appl rating as high as 4.38 at one point. His appl rating never dipped below the 4.0. He is petitioning to play 3.5. He can play on a 65 team but only at 4.0 Gene's dupr is stale at 3.5 in 2021

above 4.5 all season but fell last 2 games

Started 2025 in 4.0 with a 4.52 APPL Index

Played in merged pilot 4, 4.5 and 5.0 combined

Played one match (six games) in 2023 -- that is her only play in APPL.

She was unsure what level she was playing. Had knee issues, and has since had total knee replacement.

Approved -- self rate due to very low game record and sitting out 2 seasons.

Actual APPL Index is 2.97
Played 3.0 last season - qualifies for FAST Track

Scott wants to appeal down from a 4.06 to a 3.5 which he played at last year. He is over 65
If the teams hold up the same as they did last year his only option will be to play 50/65+ 4.0/4.5

He played all 8 matches. He won 33 games and lost 19. that is a 78% win rate.
He accrued 9 appl points in the 19 losses and allowed 7 in the 33 wins.
This is a tough one. He dominated last year. He is not far over 4.0 and yet he will be a huge disadvantage if he moves up.....He went over 4.0 in his last match.

he has no dupr

Karen is .01 off of what would be an auto appeal. Two years ago she was injured in a bicycle crash in August 2023 that broke her spine, her pelvis and her arm. It was months before she was out of the hospital and at home again. She did not play last year until May 2025 when she was finally released to do so.

Karen has been down at ACE every single day taking lessons, working on the ball machine and playing with 3.0 and 3.5 players.

Her tenacity warrants a 3.0 rating if nothing else. She was literally shattered into many pieces.

APPROVE 3.65 TO 4.0
Played all 2025 season with Meniscus tear and a lot of pain affecting his W/L. The meniscus tears in his knee (which to quote the doctor, looked like shredded crab) were surgically repaired in July and he is now back to full speed.
His team got 2nd state 2025 and will now be playing 4.0.
He won about 50% of his games with his bad knee.
He had medical issues, got them fixed and now ready to go strong....

Ron played in a 50/65 40 45 mixed league.
His rating went to 4.53 at last game from a 4.5 even. The highest he got all year was 4.55 mid season.

He plays out of Tubac which has no 4.5 team.
He won 19 games and lost 5.
He allowed 10 points and actually split 8 games. He earned 4 points.

Due to the barely over, last match, no place to play in Tubac I ask for approval.

Dupr is 4.42. Last match was one year ago.

APPROVE 3.45 TO 3.5
DUPR 3.6
DID NOT PLAY APPL 2025
PLAYED ON 3.5 IN '23
PLAYED IN ALBUQUERQUE other seasons
PLAYS AT MESA REGAL IN THEIR 3.5 GROUP

APPROVE

Paul has played MXD with his wife as his partner for 3 years. She actually applied for an appeal from 4.07 to 4.0 which we denied. We told her that her partner could apply for an appeal up and would have a better chance for approval.
Paul is 3.70

Averages almost 9 PPG
231W 217L
Will be competitive at 4.0

Dominated division
good w/l percentage 70%
and low points allowed by opponents
APPROVE