Displaying 151 - 175 of 306

 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason
17762SouthernBillGray2.733.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Bill has played on two teams this past year. He attached medical documentation of his arm being injured. His play in 2024 was steady just over the 3.0 mark. You can see the drop as 2025 goes along that lines up with this arm injury.
I am for allowing him to appeal up. He is only.02 off of an auto appeal.

17890East ValleyCandaceSharkey4.203.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Candace started 2025 season as a high 3.5 at 3.93
She stayed over 4.0 the entire season and won the majority of games in doubles and mixed.

I would suggest if she wants to play with her same partners they could possibly appeal to 4.0 as they are higher level 3.5 players as well.

Candace will be competitive at 4.0

Her reasoning to stay at 3.5 is to play with the same partners.

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
  • Medical reasoning does not support the Appeal
19332SouthernCarolStarnes3.53.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Carol has not played since 2023. The final match of the season in the final game it bumped her to 4.01 and she wants to play 3.5

I recommend we approve the appeal request.

19462SouthernCarolPinkerton-Ewens2.923.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Carol played 24 games in the 2025 season only. She won 6 and lost 18. She is eligible for a fast-track appeal to play 3.0. I do not think she should be approved for appeal to 3.5 based on her professional coach DUPR rating

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
19017West ValleyJimSeaman3.954.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Close to and above 4.0 all season.
positive w/L recors
17912SouthernGREGSCHOENBERG3.654.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

comes from small Tubac team
he states tubac needs him for the sixth male on the 50+ 4,0 team

Last year ended 3.65
50+ mixed team 1 win 9 loses
gave up 2 appl points and won 3 appl points

65+ mixed team
20 wins 22 losses
gave up 15 appl points and earned 9 appl points
65+ mens team
18 wins and 12 losses
gave up 8 appl points and earned 5 appl points

This creates a hard dilemma for the Tubac team with limited players. Greg has a much better win loss record in 65+ than in 50 +

he definitely qualifies for the 65+ no exception limit.
He really should play as an exception on the 50+ team.

check to see the number of exceptions on 50+ already

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17841SouthernCurtisSimpson4.534.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

Curtis Simpson is one of the players that caused a great deal of complaints last year regarding sandbagging. He played as a captain rated player on a 3.5 tear. He won 95 games and lost 7. At state he won 16 games and lost 3. Regular season saw him score 7 appl points in 7 losses and state had 4 appl points scored in 8 losses. Regular season saw 33 appl points scored against him in 95 wins and 5 appl points in 16 wins at state.

His dupr is 3.956. HOWEVER he plays round robin mixers at an indoor club weekly with rotating partners for that dupr score. His dupr has never been over 4.0. Pb brackets is all blurred out and I cannot see it. I do not recommend approval of the appeal

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17942SouthernDahliaBowden3.253.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Dahlia at 3.0 with her rating being set at 3.2 as a new appl player.

She had 12 wins and 12 losses 5 appl pts earned and 3 allowed. Her ending rating was a 3.25

She is under 65 so no auto approval.

While she says her coach says she should play up, her appl numbers do not warrant an appeal up. There is no data to suggest she is ready for 3.5

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17878SouthernDanaBlumberg3.33.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Dana started at 3.30 and ended at 3.30 after 32 games. she had 14 wins and 18 losses. She earned 10 appl points in the 18 losses and gave up 6 appl points in the 14 wins.

The highest she ever got was a 3.38. Never reached 3.5.
I don't think it warrants the 3.5 request.

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
19680West ValleyLISAM MATTSON3.354.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

Data does not support moving up.

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
19117SouthernDavidDenson3.53.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

David Denson is requesting to play 3.0 from 3.5. He is asking for a medical appeal due to rotator cuff surgery. He feels he will be ready by February.
HOWEVER, he has never played 3.0 in APPL. He started at 3.7 in 2023 finishing the season at 3.67. In 2024. he started the season and played the whole season at 3.67 finishing at 3.87.
He played one match in 2025 starting at 3.87 and ending at 3.74

He has a stale dupr from 2022 at 3.865.
While I understand the surgery will make a difference he is asking to appeal from 3.74 to a 3.0.

I don't know that he was ever a 3.0 player in his past.....I have mixed feeling but I am inclined to say that is too big of a drop.

18731SouthernDavidScaglione4.614.0RejectedWorkflow Complete

David has a rating of 4.61 and was asking to appeal down to continue to play with his. same team at 4.0. His main reason was his work schedule. He also stated that he would like to be hooked. up with a 4.5 team if denied.

Since Appl policy is to deny playing down except in very specific conditions (usually medical) I referred him to Scot Ritchie who is the 4.5 coordinator here in Tucson.

Recommend denial due to Appl policy.

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
18757SouthernDeeDeeCherubini4.444.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

DeeDee Cherubini is requesting a rate appeal from 4.44 to 4.5. She played 4.0 last year so is not eligible for an autoappeal.

DeeDee was on my team in 2024 and went to Nationals with us and was a big key to our winning the tournament.

DeeDee played on a 4.0 mixed team. She won 15 games and lost one.

She played in a mixed league with 50+ and 18+ women teams. She won 20 games and lost 4.

At state the mixed team took 1st place and the women's team took second.
Her DUPR is a 4.458

DeeDee is well-rounded player still in her 30's and could be an asset to Appl for many years to come.

I request that she be allowed to to appeal to 4.5
17945SouthernArdean Nickersonnickerson3.103.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

denied except for 65+

she wants to play on a 65+ team

won 10 lost 20 at 3.0
allowed 8 appl earned 8 appl

Her scores don't relay the ability to move to 3.5. Only the 65+ appeal will help her.

  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
19590East ValleyDonnaRutledge3.02.5RejectedWorkflow Complete

Deny
3.0 to 2.5
Dominated at 2.5
Averaged 10 ppg
Won almost 75% of games
Won state tournament at 2.5

  • Information provided does not support the Appeal
  • APPL history of results does not support the Appeal
17790SouthernSherryElwood2.53.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Deny this appeal. Player qualifies for a fast track appeal. Rating is 2.85. Told her this and asked her to submit a fast track appeal. 8/4/25

or approve this one
18297West ValleyWayneMosser4.354.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2024 or 2025 seasons

Self rate through appeal process
18296West ValleyPatrickHansen4.434.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

did not play in 2025

DUPR recent, and above 4.5

Self rate through appeal
19614West ValleyLoriUtley4.03.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025

Medical
18303West ValleyKaraLandauer4.544.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025

Self rate through Appeal
18249West ValleyOliviaNichols3.504.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025

Self rating
18765West ValleyLaurieWilhelm4.003.5ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025
Self rating through appeal process
18847West ValleyPaulOlson4.744.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025
Self rating through Appeal process
18740West ValleyDelynnMurray2.493.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025
Self rating through appeals process
17814SouthernPamHolmes2.893.0ApprovedWorkflow Complete

Did not play in 2025 due to injury

2024 14 wins 15 losses earned 8 appl points, allowed 5
never rose above the 3.1 mark in 2024
Injured in 2025, back surgery
no pb or dupr ratings

would have qualified for a fast track appeal. Recommend approval.

 Entry ID Region First Last APPL Index Appeal To Workflow Status Workflow Step Internal Review Notes Reject Reason