Roster Rating Standard Appeal

• Duplicate Appeal

YES APPROVE APPEAL Greg M agrees

75 yr old playing 65+ wants to go TO 2.5 from 3.1.
DID NOT dominate @2.5
LOST majority of games @ 2.5 and split a few @ 2.5
12 :12
Femme is where she need to be

first year was 2025
w 24 losses 10
high point scores on losses to add to team totals

Nancy has been a solid 3.0 player for several years. As a coach/captain, Nancy ends up playing with the players no one else wants to play with. Nancy has a good well rounded game. She dinks, can do overheads and thinks about strategy. Nancy is very slightly built and I believe her lack of strength is the only thing that keeps her from being a 3.5 player. I would approve Nancy's appeal as she has done the work to be a 3.0 but constantly puts others first. Her average rating this past year is 2.917 which is well within the auto appeal boundaries.

This one was a real pain. I had to look up every single person played as there is no indication within the rating if they were the 18+ team.....ugh

As a 50+ player. He won 15 games, lost 23
Earned 12 appl points and allowed 6.

Against the 18+ he won 2 games, lost 8
Earned 3 appl points and allowed 2

This player was born in 1961 In his losses he lost 1 game to players born in 1976 and 1979
2 games to players born in 1993 and 1966
and 2 games to players born in 1970 and 1969
He lost one game to players born in 1990 and 2000

3 of his games lost were to people less than 10 years younger than him.

In the 18+ matches his rating dropped a total of .15. Added back into his final rating that brings him to a 2.93. Enough for an auto appeal.

• Duplicate Appeal

w 3, l- 18
had surgery
2025 first year, probably should have started at 3.0

APPROVE to 3.0
HOVERING AT 3.99 2025
Last 4 games 2.93 to
2.79 just the last 4 games
263 won 246 lost
50% win/loss

• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

Sue is a 3.57 player who is asking to play down to a 3.0. She is 75 years old and wants to play doubles with her husband who is a 3.0 and is 82 years old. She was quite sick this past spring and has had a hard time recovering.

Sue and her husband played together last year in 30 games. They won 22 and lost 8. They gained 6 Appl points and allowed 12.

Sue's rating bobbed around all year going between the 3.37 she started with and peaked for one game at 3.6 before going back to a 3.55. While she was over 3.5 most of the season it was usually 3.51, 3.55.... she only hit 3.6 at one time and only for one game of one match.

While her husband COULD play up on a 3.5 team due to his age, his ratings are continuously low 3.2.

with that being said, is she better than 3.0 yes, at 75 playing a a 65+ should that give her some grace when she plays with an 82 year old partner.....

My feelings are if they are husband and wife and can even stand to play together on the same side.... they must be amazing people. I would vote yes based on age. But I realize I am pretty tenderhearted when it come to things like this.