Roster Rating Standard Appeal

Karen is requesting approval to play down from 3.54 to 3.0. She has not been active in Appl since 2023.
She played 3.0 in in 2022 starting at 3.2 and ending at 3.54. As a 3.0 she won 39 games and lost 9. She was moved to 3.5 with her starting rating of 3.54
as a 3.5 player she won 18 games and loss 40.
Her rating in 3.5 in 19 of the 58 games reached 3.5, while going no higher than 3.57. The rest of the games her rating was 3.5 or below.

Karen has taken it upon herself to do the self-rating and rated out at 3.0. I have known Karen since 2021 and know her to be honest and straightforward. My teams have played against her over the years as 3.0 and 3.5. She only won one game of my teams in any of the encounters. We played her 4x over two seasons.

I believe that Karen would do well in the 3.0 league and be able to build back up to the 3.5 level.

Audrey is requesting an appeal from 3.24 to 3.5. She feels that the Appl index does not adequately show her skills.
In 2025 she played 3.5 winning 8 games and losing 10. her index started at 3.23 and ended at 2.34
In 2024 she played 3.5 and started at 3.27 and went down to 3.23
playing 3.0 in 2023 she started at the assigned 3.2 level and increased to 3.27 as a 3.0.

I just don't see that there is any marked improvement over a three year span that warrants such a high rating jump. I recommend she be denied,

• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

David has a rating of 4.61 and was asking to appeal down to continue to play with his. same team at 4.0. His main reason was his work schedule. He also stated that he would like to be hooked. up with a 4.5 team if denied.

Since Appl policy is to deny playing down except in very specific conditions (usually medical) I referred him to Scot Ritchie who is the 4.5 coordinator here in Tucson.

Recommend denial due to Appl policy.

• APPL history of results does not support the Appeal

FAST TRACK
Played 4.0 in 25

DeeDee Cherubini is requesting a rate appeal from 4.44 to 4.5. She played 4.0 last year so is not eligible for an autoappeal.

DeeDee was on my team in 2024 and went to Nationals with us and was a big key to our winning the tournament.

DeeDee played on a 4.0 mixed team. She won 15 games and lost one.

She played in a mixed league with 50+ and 18+ women teams. She won 20 games and lost 4.

At state the mixed team took 1st place and the women's team took second.
Her DUPR is a 4.458

DeeDee is well-rounded player still in her 30's and could be an asset to Appl for many years to come.

I request that she be allowed to to appeal to 4.5

Did not play in 2025
Self rating through appeal process

• Player is already at the desired Roster Rating

Played with 18+ mixed flights, scores counted
close to 4.0 both seasons played

Approved

first year was 2025
w 24 losses 10
high point scores on losses to add to team totals